RankScoreGenreGame
201.8.13RPGThe Sims™ 3
202.8.12ActionEarthworm Jim 1 + 2
203.8.12SportUltimate Soccer Manager
204.8.12MultiplayerKongai
205.8.12ActionQUAKE II
206.8.12ActionRaptor: Call of the Shadows 2010 Edition
207.8.12RPGGothic
208.8.12StrategyDesktop Tower Defense
209.8.12AdventureBroken Sword 2: Remastered + The Original Game
210.8.11AdventureSyberia
211.8.11StrategyFantasy General
212.8.10ActionThief
213.8.09StrategyKingdom Rush Frontiers
214.8.09PuzzleDoodle God
215.8.09ActionHAWKEN
216.8.08RPGFallout: New Vegas
217.8.08ActionFar Cry®
218.8.08SportNeed for Speed
219.8.08MultiplayerRealm of the Mad God
220.8.07StrategyCommandos Ammo Pack
221.8.07StrategyZeus + Poseidon (Acropolis)
222.8.07AdventureTex Murphy: Under a Killing Moon
223.8.07StrategyPharaoh + Cleopatra
224.8.07StrategyCursed Treasure: Don't Touch My Gems!
225.8.07StrategyBloons Tower Defense 4
226.8.06RPGUltima™ 4: Quest of the Avatar
227.8.06AdventureGabriel Knight 2: The Beast Within
228.8.06RPGStonekeep
229.8.06MultiplayerThe Last Stand: Dead Zone
230.8.06AdventureRiven: The Sequel to Myst
231.8.05ActionLoadout
232.8.04ActionLearn to Fly
233.8.04StrategySonny
234.8.04MultiplayerCrazy Fairies
235.8.04ActionDescent 3 + Expansion
236.8.04StrategyDisciples 2 Gold
237.8.03StrategyGemCraft
238.8.03AdventureInfectonator : World Dominator
239.8.03ActionPrince of Persia®: The Sands of Time
240.8.02ActionBurrito Bison Revenge
241.8.02StrategyS2: Silent Storm Gold Edition
242.8.02ActionHalf-Life 2
243.8.02StrategyStartopia
244.8.01AdventurePapers, Please
245.8.01StrategyStronghold Crusader HD
246.8.01RPGTorchlight
247.8.00ActionRush Team Free FPS Multiplayers
248.8.00ActionTorchlight II
249.8.00ActionOddworld: Abe's Oddysee
250.7.99RPGNox™
251.7.99ActionUPGRADE COMPLETE!
252.7.99StrategyRebuild 2
253.7.99ActionKilling Floor
254.7.98RPGKing's Bounty: The Legend
255.7.98RPGMight and Magic® 7: For Blood and Honor™
256.7.98StrategyPirates! Gold Plus
257.7.98ActionMDK 2
258.7.97AdventureReal Myst
259.7.97ActionJust Cause 2
260.7.97StrategyCursed Treasure: Level Pack!
261.7.96ActionSyndicate Plus™
262.7.96ActionMount & Blade: Warband
263.7.96AdventureTex Murphy: The Pandora Directive
264.7.96ActionElephant Quest
265.7.96AdventureInfectonator 2
266.7.96AdventureTo The Moon
267.7.95StrategyMastermind: World Conquerer
268.7.95ActionCrusader: No Remorse™
269.7.95ActionAlone in the Dark 1+2+3
270.7.95ActionThe Last Stand: Union City
271.7.94ActionWing Commander ®: Privateer ™
272.7.94ActionUnreal Gold
273.7.94StrategyCursed Treasure 2
274.7.93MultiplayerSAS: Zombie Assault 3
275.7.93StrategyAge of Wonders
276.7.92ActionCall of Duty®: Modern Warfare® 3
277.7.92ActionStrike Force Heroes
278.7.92MultiplayerPlatform Racing 2
279.7.92ActionWing Commander™ 4: The Price of Freedom
280.7.91AdventureSimon the Sorcerer
281.7.91StrategyCommand & Conquer
282.7.91StrategyChaos Overlords
283.7.90StrategyThe King's League: Odyssey
284.7.90StrategyHeroes of Might and Magic®
285.7.90MultiplayerTDP4 Team Battle
286.7.89MultiplayerTransformice
287.7.89StrategyConstructor
288.7.89StrategyAge of Wonders: Shadow Magic
289.7.89StrategyCompany of Heroes 2
290.7.88SportWinter Olympics
291.7.88AdventureDishonored
292.7.88SportFlatOut
293.7.88StrategyEpic War 3
294.7.88ActionBatman: Arkham City - Game of the Year Edition
295.7.87ActionBattlefield: Bad Company™ 2
296.7.87SportNew Star Soccer
297.7.87ActionIL-2 Sturmovik™: 1946
298.7.86StrategyEpic War 4
299.7.86MultiplayerRIFT
300.7.86AdventureMachinarium: Collector's Edition
 
Follow us on Twitter: @5000best
5000 Best Games by Arek Paterek (Twitter), 2014.
Score is based on my judgement, Steam, GOG, and Kongregate.