RankScoreGenreGame
101.8.45MultiplayerGarry's Mod
102.8.45StrategyCommand & Conquer: Red Alert
103.8.43AdventureQuest for Glory 1-5
104.8.43RPGNetHack
105.8.43StrategyBloons TD 5
106.8.43StrategyAge of Empires II HD
107.8.43RPGNeverwinter Nights: Diamond Edition
108.8.43ActionCarmageddon Max Pack
109.8.43StrategyIncredible Machine Mega Pack, The
110.8.42MultiplayerContract Wars
111.8.42SportGrand Theft Auto
112.8.42AdventureLittle Big Adventure 2 (Twinsen's Odyssey)
113.8.41RPGRust
114.8.41ActionWing Commander™ 1+2
115.8.41StrategyDungeon Keeper™ 2
116.8.41StrategyBattle Isle Platinum (includes Incubation)
117.8.40RPGUltima® Underworld 1+2
118.8.40StrategyImperialism
119.8.39ActionCannon Fodder
120.8.39ActionWing Commander™ 3 Heart of the Tiger™
121.8.38StrategyRollerCoaster Tycoon 2: Triple Thrill Pack
122.8.37ActionPainkiller Black Edition
123.8.37MultiplayerCounter-Strike: Source
124.8.36ActionQUAKE III: Team Arena
125.8.36RPGPAYDAY 2
126.8.36AdventureMyst: Masterpiece Edition
127.8.35ActionLeft 4 Dead 2
128.8.35ActionBeyond Good and Evil™
129.8.35ActionFreefall Tournament
130.8.35StrategyIdle Mine
131.8.35ActionTyrian 2000
132.8.35ActionDayZ
133.8.35ActionThief™ 2: The Metal Age
134.8.35RPGUltima™ 7 The Complete Edition
135.8.33ActionPrince of Persia
136.8.32StrategyTotal War™: ROME II
137.8.32AdventureLongest Journey, The
138.8.32SportInterstate '76 Arsenal, The
139.8.31MultiplayerClash of the Dragons
140.8.31MultiplayerHD Xyth
141.8.31ActionWar Inc. Battlezone
142.8.30StrategyEmpire Earth: Gold Edition
143.8.30RPGIcewind Dale Complete
144.8.30ActionArma 3
145.8.29AdventureSanitarium
146.8.29RPGMight and Magic® 6-pack: Limited Edition
147.8.29ActionGiants: Citizen Kabuto
148.8.28ActionTerraria
149.8.28MultiplayerCS Portable
150.8.28ActionWarframe
151.8.28ActionPath of Exile
152.8.27ActionOutcast
153.8.27AdventureBroken Sword: Director's Cut + The Original Game
154.8.27ActionShogo: Mobile Armor Division
155.8.27ActionLearn to Fly 2
156.8.26ActionSouth Park™: The Stick of Truth™
157.8.26MultiplayerThe Necronomicon
158.8.25AdventureGabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers
159.8.25RPGDivine Divinity
160.8.24MultiplayerRed Crucible 2
161.8.24RPGBorderlands 2
162.8.24ActionFreespace + Expansion
163.8.23ActionStarbound
164.8.23StrategySacrifice
165.8.22ActionLegacy of Kain: Soul Reaver
166.8.22RPGGothic 2 Gold Edition
167.8.22ActionDark Souls™: Prepare To Die™ Edition
168.8.21RPGIcewind Dale 2 Complete
169.8.21StrategyDungeon Keeper Gold™
170.8.21ActionMortal Kombat
171.8.20StrategyKing of Dragon Pass
172.8.19SportStunts
173.8.19ActionPlanetSide 2
174.8.18StrategyEvil Genius
175.8.18AdventureAnother World: 20th Anniversary Edition
176.8.17StrategyFTL: Faster Than Light
177.8.17MultiplayerWar Thunder
178.8.17RPGLegend of Grimrock
179.8.17StrategyBanished
180.8.17ActionMedal of Honor: Allied Assault War Chest
181.8.16ActionBioShock Infinite
182.8.16RPGCrusader Kings II
183.8.16StrategyShogun: Total War
184.8.16RPGEpic Battle Fantasy 4
185.8.16ActionPortal 2
186.8.15SportFootball Manager 2013
187.8.15ActionFar Cry 3
188.8.15StrategyEmpire: Total War™
189.8.15StrategyStronghold HD
190.8.15ActionGrand Theft Auto IV
191.8.15ActionThe Mighty Quest For Epic Loot
192.8.14AdventurePhantasmagoria
193.8.14ActionThe Binding of Isaac
194.8.14ActionHalf-Life
195.8.14ActionSuper Mario Bros.
196.8.14MultiplayerSpiral Knights
197.8.14RPGAge of Wonders III
198.8.14ActionNeverwinter
199.8.13ActionMDK
200.8.13ActionUnreal Tournament 2004 ECE
 
Follow us on Twitter: @5000best
5000 Best Games by Arek Paterek (Twitter), 2014.
Score is based on my judgement, Steam, GOG, and Kongregate.